A balance transfer credit card moves an existing high-interest debt — usually 19.99–22.99% on another credit card — to a new card at a promotional low rate, typically 0–1.99% for 6–12 months. The savings can be real, but every product on the Canadian market has at least one quiet detail that erodes the headline rate. This page covers the four cards worth comparing, the actual math, and the situations where balance transfers go wrong.
What makes a Canadian balance transfer card "good" in 2026
- Promotional rate at or below 2% for at least 6 months.
- Balance transfer fee at or below 3% of the transferred amount.
- Clear, predictable rate after the promo period (the "go-to" APR).
- Minimum payments calculated on the principal, not just interest.
The four worth comparing
- MBNA True Line Mastercard — 0% for 12 months on balance transfers, 3% transfer fee, then go-to 12.99%. Among the lowest go-to rates in Canada, which matters if you don't pay off in the promo window.
- Scotiabank Value Visa — 0.99% for 6 months, 1% transfer fee, then go-to 13.99%. $29 annual fee. The 1% transfer fee is the lowest of the four; the 6-month window is the shortest.
- BMO Preferred Rate Mastercard — 0.99% for 9 months, 2% transfer fee, then go-to 12.99%. $20 annual fee. Middle of the pack on all dimensions; clean balance of promo length and fees.
- CIBC Select Visa — 0% for 10 months, 1% transfer fee, then go-to 13.99%. $29 annual fee. Strong combination if you want a longer promo at a low fee, and CIBC sometimes runs targeted promos at 0% transfer fee for new clients.
The math: which one saves the most?
For a $5,000 transfer paid off in equal monthly installments over the promo window, the all-in cost (transfer fee + accrued interest at the promo rate) lands roughly here:
- MBNA True Line (0% × 12 months, 3% fee): ~$150 total cost ($150 transfer fee + $0 interest if fully paid off in 12 months).
- Scotia Value Visa (0.99% × 6 months, 1% fee): ~$76 ($50 fee + ~$14 interest + $29 annual fee, if paid off in 6 months). But you have to pay off $5,000 in 6 months — $833/month minimum.
- BMO Preferred Rate (0.99% × 9 months, 2% fee): ~$133 ($100 fee + ~$22 interest + $20 annual fee, if paid off in 9 months).
- CIBC Select Visa (0% × 10 months, 1% fee): ~$79 ($50 fee + $0 interest + $29 annual fee, if paid off in 10 months).
Versus carrying the same $5,000 at 19.99% on the original card for the same window: ~$500–700 in interest. The savings vs. doing nothing are dramatic; the difference between the four cards is small.
The fine print that wrecks the savings
- New purchases erode the math. On almost all Canadian balance transfer cards, new purchases made on the card accrue interest at the standard rate (19.99–22.99%) from the date of purchase, not from the end of the promo. Payments are typically applied to the lowest-rate balance first (the promo transfer), meaning new-purchase debt sits at full APR until the promo balance is gone. Do not use the balance transfer card for new spending.
- End-of-promo cliff. The day after the promo ends, the entire remaining balance jumps to the go-to rate. If you haven't paid it off, the savings vanish quickly. Set a calendar reminder for one month before promo end.
- Late payment kills the promo. Most issuers reserve the right to cancel the promotional rate on a single missed or late payment. Auto-pay the minimum at minimum.
- Transfers from same-issuer cards aren't allowed. You can't transfer an existing CIBC balance to a CIBC Select Visa, etc. Cross-issuer transfers only.
When a balance transfer isn't the right move
If you can't realistically pay off the transferred balance during the promo window, the cliff-rate math may make a personal line of credit (typically 7–12% with no expiry) cheaper. If the underlying debt is small (under $2,000), the transfer fee plus annual fee can wipe out the savings. If you're using the transfer to free up the original card for more spending, the math reverses entirely.
Related reading
- MBNA True Line Mastercard review
- Scotiabank Value Visa review
- BMO Preferred Rate Mastercard review
- Methodology & fact-verification